A revolving door in Boston: Worst fears realized! Red Sox radio will use a scorecard full of announcers

History strongly suggests that a bloated framework of guest broadcasters is doomed for failure.


WEEI flauntingly released its panoply of new Red Sox announcers for the 2019 season.

The headline read, “Sean McDonough, Josh Lewin, Mario Impemba, Chris Berman, Lou Merloni, Dale Arnold, Tom Caron and Dave O’Brien to participate in the 2019 Season.” Below it, a sub-headline added, “Veteran Broadcaster Joe Castiglione Signs Extension.”

One important disclaimer, this isn’t a commentary on any of these accomplished broadcasters individually. 

When word leaked out last fall that Sox radio was going to a play-by-play/talk format, it was vehemently denied by the big thinkers at the station.The team too said it wouldn’t stand for anything like it.

After denials and more denials; the Red Sox Network is tearing down a 75 year New England tradition.

On the eve of spring training, the broadcasts aren’t going to two man talk. They’re not even going to a three man talk. They’re going to Town Hall Talk. There will be at least nine announcers rotating through the season in the broadcasts.

Most broadcasts will feature Joe Castiglione plus the flavor of the day. A broadcast team is generally made up of two or sometimes three announcers. Nine guys make a baseball team not a broadcast team.So bring your scorecard for the surprise of the day. 

But that’s okay. WEEI pays tons for the rights and this outlandish format affords the station ten sales opportunities. Let’s see.

  1. People in-town and out-of-town will be shuffling in and out of Fenway, so WEEI can pitch Uber to serve as the official car service of Red Sox Radio.
  1. Boston’s Elite Protective Services can sponsor celebrity protection. Chris Berman, an ESPN original, needs a body guard. When he’s approached for an autograph, the Elite guards can strut their strength and gruffly shout, “Back, back, back.”
  1. Because the station will be welcoming new broadcasters every few nights, Boston Balloon Events and The Confetti Company can dress up the booth accordingly. 
  1. Aaron’s might be interested in sponsoring the chair rental for the booth. It will be crowded.
  1. Because the entrance to the radio booth will be busy, there might be consideration for constructing a revolving door, sponsored by Hub Glass Services in Sommerville.
  1. And if these guest announcers will be in Boston more than just a few days, Back Bay Dry Cleaners might sponsor the required valet services.
  1. Since this is a lab experiment, (I hope it’s not permanent), WEEI might also sell signage on the back of the white lab coats that the broadcasters will be required to wear in the booth. There’s a Quest Diagnostics near Fenway Park.
  1. The station’s promotion’s manager has opportunities too. The first caller who can identify the last three guest announcers can enjoy a day in the booth. But in the crowded booth winners have to stand. So they’ll get a free pair of comfortable shoes, sponsored by Bostonian.
  1. Staples might want to sponsor the season-long index cards that poor Joe Castiglione will need; one index card every game, plastered saliently right in front of him, his guest partner’s first name in bright ink and large font. Joe doesn’t want to mistakenly call Chris Berman, Mario. Staples also sells name tags in case all nine announcers show up the same night.
  1. If the broadcasts turn into a circus, which there’s a good chance it will, Boston Clown might have an interest in buying a couple spots too.

Okay! maybe these jokes are a failed attempt at ugly humor. But the whole new format is the real joke. And what will we do when Castiglione takes his vacation days? Remember he’s the fellow who has to hold down the fort. When he’s gone (about 18 games), they’ll really need a security force.

Actually, I’m sure WEEI has something creative planned when Joe’s gone. The talk guys from the station doing the whole game off a screen in the studio?  AI (Artificial Intelligence) mysteriously taking over the broadcasts? If it doesn’t work, how about a couple colorful Massachusetts politicians, Elizabeth Warren and Barney Frank? Perhaps they’ll stimulate a Donald Trump tweet. A Trump tweet will generate some curious attention. Maybe bring in Terry Cashman to sing his famous ode to the Red Sox. It can be simulcast on some oldies station too.

Let’s start with some history. WEEI’s idea is not novel.

Management should do a little digging. It’s a matter of public record. The Atlanta Falcons tried doing this in the early 80s one season. That was that. And with football it’s easier. And football is less about a comfortable radio companion every day. It’s about rapid-fire delivery of information and a little depth from a color commentator.

As my mother-in-law used to tell me, live and learn. She also said, grin and bear it.

NBC Sports had guest color commentators working with Curt Gowdy on its baseball broadcasts in 1973 and ’74. ( Curt was the Voice of the Red Sox from 1951-65 and would likely turn over in his grave if he heard this brilliant idea activated. Curt would know. He also owned and managed radio stations.)  

NBC had guests joining Gowdy; different ones each week. It obviously didn’t last. It was a novelty. Television is different and a national broadcast is a whole other animal with an entertaining dynamic. The guests included football’s Don Meredith, Emmett Ashford, (baseball’s first African-American umpire), Chuck Connors (The Rifleman on TV and ex-baseballer), Danny Kaye (actor who invested in the Seattle Mariners), George C. Scott and others.

After two years, the guests were gone and from what I remember, Gowdy and Joe Garagiola split the package the following season.

They’re not bringing in Berman, Merloni or Carmon to showcase their fundamental baseball play-by-play skills because they have none. Their skill-sets are strong but for other facets of broadcasting. Last time I looked, radio is about painting a picture.

Isn’t teamwork built by collaborating together, cohesively and regularly? Isn’t radio baseball about listeners developing a friendship, a sense of  companionship all summer? All this new format will do is chase more people away. NBC’s experiment with guest announcers didn’t light up the ratings. For fans, radio is about enjoying and absorbing a daily, symbiotic broadcast relationship. It’s stepping into a comfortable pair of shoes everyday, not a new uncomfortable pair every couple days. 

Isn’t it about Curt Gowdy saying “Hi neighbor. Have a ‘Ganset?” isn’t that what radio baseball is all about? Well, maybe Ganset has long since been overtaken like Ballantine, Rheingold and other regional beers. But you get the drift.

As Winston Churchill told the House of Commons in 1948, “Those who fail to learn from history are condemned to repeat it.” A hodgepodge of guest broadcasters didn’t work effectively on NBC and it didn’t work locally for football and certainly won’t locally for baseball, a six month everyday sport. Team commentators have to be emotionally linked to the team that they’re covering. Let’s not reinvent the wheel.

It’s one thing to bring in Ronald Reagan as Harry Caray did in Chicago once, but a cast (the word used in Boston to introduce the conceptual framework) is for a Broadway show or a Hollywood motion picture, not for a baseball radio booth.

The exogenous presence of guest announcers will likely produce extraneous conversation. Castiglione will be tempted, as any decent announcer would be, to ask his guests questions about baseball in general, their careers or how they spend their summers. So the broadcasts are likely to drift to the superfluous. It’s like having a strange guest in your home four nights a week. It’s much.

Baseball broadcasts are about chemistry. It’s Caray and Buck, Harwell and Carry, Murphy and Thorne, Scully and Doggett, Hodges and Simmons, Prince and Woods, even, yes, for some, Sterling and Waldman. In Boston, it’s been Gowdy and Martin, Star and Castiglione, Coleman and Martin and other wonderful duos.

 As Phil Rizzuto said when the roster of Yankees broadcasters turned into a mini phone book, “I’m getting spiked on my way into the booth.”

Now  it’s Castiglione and McDonough, Berman, O’Brien, Impemba, Arnold, Merloni, Caron, Lewin and…(I’m out of space.)


Happy President’s Day; Halby’s All Presidents baseball team:

Battery: Gary Carter and Whitey Ford

Infield: Von Hayes, Adam Kennedy, Davey Johnson and Tony Taylor

Outfield: Reggie Jackson, Hack Wilson, Claudell Washington


David J. Halberstam

David is a 40-year + industry veteran who served as play-by-play announcer for St. John's University basketball in New York and as radio play-by-play voice of the Miami Heat in South Florida. He is the author of Sports on New York Radio: A Play-by-Play History and The Fundamentals of Sports Media and Sponsorship Sales: Developing New Accounts.

Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael Green
5 years ago

The one time this approach made sense was when the Mariners rotated guests for a couple of years after Dave Niehaus’s death, partly on the theory, it appears, that he was so (deservedly) big and beloved in Seattle that it wouldn’t be fair to whoever they hired to sit in his chair. Then they went with a fine young broadcaster, Adam Goldsmith. I like Tim Neverett, and I look forward to him on Dodger broadcasts, but he’s not Dave Niehaus and this isn’t Seattle. When Harry Caray had a stroke in 1987, the Cubs used guests for about six weeks.… Read more »